Stand at Fourth Avenue and William Street in downtown Post Falls today and you will see a white frame church with a tall steeple, now home to the Jacklin Arts and Cultural Center at 405 North William Street. It looks as if it has always stood on that corner. It has not. The building arrived there in pieces of a sort — two whole churches, built in two different parts of town, hauled together by horses and joined into one.
The older half was built in 1890, the year before Post Falls incorporated, when the First Methodist Episcopal Church rose during the town's first establishment. Built to a Methodist Church Extension plan, it held a sanctuary about 50 feet by 32 feet with a Sunday school and entrance hall beside it, Gothic-arched windows, colored leaded glass, and a bell tower topped by a lofty steeple. The National Register nomination calls it apparently the first Methodist Episcopal Church building erected in the five northern counties of Idaho, and one of the earliest examples of Gothic Revival architecture in North Idaho. Nine years later, in 1899, the First Presbyterian Church was built across town at the northwest corner of Second Avenue and Henry Street, a plainer vernacular church for a growing mill town.
In 1921, the Reverend Nathan Fiske encouraged the two congregations to do something practical and remarkable: combine. Drawn by horses, both buildings were moved to the northwest corner of Fourth and William and joined on the new site. The former Methodist building became the sanctuary, and the former Presbyterian building became the Christian education wing. Together they took a new name, the Community Presbyterian Church, and the joined building marked a second chapter in Kootenai County religious life — a move from separate, sectarian beginnings toward one interdenominational community church. That layered significance, both architectural and communal, earned it a place on the National Register of Historic Places on September 7, 1984.
Downtown changed around it through the decades, and by the late twentieth century the old church nearly disappeared. Plans called for demolishing the building and paving its lots for a parking lot. In 1998, Susan Jacklin formed Community Building Partners Inc., which purchased the church and the land it sat on and gave it a simpler name that locals already used: the Old Church. What followed was not a quick repair but a long rescue.
Following a restoration of nearly ten years and more than a million dollars in donations, the Old Church reopened in May 2005 as the Jacklin Arts and Cultural Center. The sanctuary built in 1890 now hosts concerts, exhibits, weddings, and community gatherings instead of Sunday services, and in 2021 the center celebrated 100 years of the church in its current location. For a downtown that has watched mills burn, hotels rise and fall, and streets change names, the joined church endures as proof of a Post Falls habit worth remembering: when something matters to this town, its people find a way to move it, mend it, and keep it standing together.